OLD STEAM NAVY [ MORE REVIEWS ] [ WEBSITE ] [ NEW STORIES ]

First Look Review
USS New Ironsides
USS New Ironsides. Old Steam Navy, resin, 1/240th scale.
  • newironsideslarge

by: Devin [ DEVIN ]

The Ship

The USS New Ironsides was one of the three initial ironclad designs approved by the U.S. Government in the early days of the American Civil War to counter the impending threat of the CSS Virginia and other Confederate armored ships. The ship mounted fourteen 11" Dahlgren smoothbore cannons on specially designed slide mounts, and two 150lb. Parrot rifles. She proved such a nuisance that the Confederates offered a bounty of $100,000 to anyone who could sink her (this was double what was offered for a monitor sinking). She survived the war only to be lost to an accidental fire while laid-up in ordinary at the League Island Navy Yard on December 16, 1866.

The Kit

This kit is the latest offering from Old Steam Navy as part of their Siege of Charleston collection. The kit is resin, white metal, and etched brass in 1/240th scale.The hull is cast one piece, full hull, a solid block of resin 11 5/8" overall length and 2 13/16" wide. This scales out perfectly for 1/240th scale, according to the published dimensions of the full sized ship and plans from various sources. All of the deck fittings are separate castings, leaving a smooth expanse of deck scribed with planking detail. With the omitted details this would be a great subject to try planking with real wood if one is so inclined. The hull sides have the waterline armor belt and the vertical battery armor applied. To my eye this detail is a little soft and needs sanding to even it out in some areas, but it's nothing that some sanding sticks and maybe a scribing tool can't clean up, and is nothing that those used to resin kits will have any trouble with. Please note that the photo of the keel is not typical for this kit, I told Old Steam that I would take a unit with some keel issues as I may build my model as a waterline display.

Besides the hull, the other resin pieces of this kit are the ship's boats. They are well cast on the outside, and the inside is taken care of by inserts from the extensive sheets of photo etch brass. The white metal parts make up the majority of the other fittings, such as the skylights, pilot house, anchors, mast base, rudder and vents. All of the white metal parts are extremely well cast and are free of most of the soft detail problems that one commonly sees in such components. There are a lot of extra small parts in this kit. Tungsten wire for rigging the barricades. Chain for the anchors. Wood dowels for signal masts. Brass tubing for the stack and smaller tubing for the guns. There's even a selection of injection molded plastic rivets to detail the brass gun shutters. These pieces will allow the modeler to do the various bits of scratch building that are required for this model.

The photo etch is my favorite part of this kit. There are two thicknesses to the relief-etched sheets, one is .01" and the other .025". The thinner sheet has standard structural parts one would expect, such as the boat interiors and rudders, gun shutters, mast details, cleats, ladders, etc. Several of the parts are made up by folding into thicker structural pieces, and some items such as the boat davit pulleys are made up of multiple relief-etched brass parts that will build into realistic 3D assemblies.


The thicker sheet has the barricade struts and boat davits along with two etched guides for building up the large barricades that ran along the edge of New Ironsides' deck. The plans include a full size template that you cut out and tape to the deck which tells you where to lay down the drilling templates. You then drill for the etched locating pins in the barricade support struts. The whole process should make for a relatively easy and error free build of what could have been a mess of individual supports and slats.


Instructions

The instructions come in two parts. The first 14 pages are an extensive history of the USS New Ironsides, complete with photos and sketches.

The second part is 14 pages consisting of an itemized part list, a detailed drawing of each sheet of photo etch that annotates the name of each piece. The balance of the pages are step-by-step instructions, complete with CAD Drawings of assembly, color photos of completed assemblies, and the previously mentioned templates. Also included is a fold out full-size 1/24th scale plan of the ship as she appeared during the war, showing her in plan, profile and stern view.
SUMMARY
Highs: The photo etch is stunning, and the white metal parts are as good as you will see in any multi-media kit. While there is some scratch building required, nearly every piece needed to complete the kit is included. The instructions are also well done.
Lows: The hull does require some clean up, but nothing outside of what most resin kits require. Some scratch building is required, and I do not personally consider that a problem, but some may find that time consuming.
Verdict: The hull requires cleanup as on any resin kit, but everything else is a step above in the terms of quality. The scale of 1/240 is a bit odd, but the subject matter is unique enough that the model should do well in any modelers hands.
Percentage Rating
90%
  Scale: Other
  Mfg. ID: New Ironsides
  Suggested Retail: 179.95
  PUBLISHED: Jul 15, 2008
  NATIONALITY: United States
NETWORK-WIDE AVERAGE RATINGS
  THIS REVIEWER: 93.00%
  MAKER/PUBLISHER: 90.00%

About Devin (Devin)
FROM: NEW JERSEY, UNITED STATES

I started modeling young, when my father bought me a semi-tractor kit around the age of 6. The real modeling started after Star Wars came out in 1977, and then when I got interested in WWII in my early teens. I spend most of my time modeling ships, due to their complexity, but I also build aircraf...

Copyright ©2021 text by Devin [ DEVIN ]. Images also by copyright holder unless otherwise noted. Opinions expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of Model Shipwrights. All rights reserved.



Comments

The link seems to be broken...
JUL 23, 2008 - 03:24 AM
Thanks Martin, all good now.......
JUL 23, 2008 - 03:30 AM
Very interesting subject. Thanks for the review Devin. Kenny
JUL 23, 2008 - 05:17 AM
ditto, interesting subject! I wish I had more time..and space..and money..
JUL 24, 2008 - 10:05 AM
   
ADVERTISEMENT


Photos
Click image to enlarge
  • newironsideslarge
  • IMG_16261
  • IMG_16273
  • IMG_16281
  • IMG_16291
  • IMG_16302
  • IMG_16311
  • IMG_16323
  • IMG_16333
  • IMG_16343
  • IMG_16352
  • IMG_16361
  • IMG_16372
  • brass-a
  • brass-b
ADVERTISEMENT