Hhaarrrr
Man the cannons, ready the grapplehooks, prepare the boarding party.....Hoist the Jolly Roger..
:-) :-) :-)
Hi Skipper,
Sure, we can disscus this in peace. You are right, sails do get very dirty, and will look very patchy and worn. Depending on the type of fabric used, they can indeed look very dark. I don't think however that todays sails are representative of the sails which were used in the days when sail was the only means of propulsion. Main sails would be used continuesly, and not realy have a change to rot. Todays sails spend a lot of time either in storage or reefed (rolled up) which is where rot set in quick. Salt water spray would stain the sails, especialy the lower ones. Also the quality of the sails would in the main have been top class, as you couldn't risk ending up without decent sails in the middle of the ocean. I suppose it also depends on the era and user. Patched up, yes definitely. But to show this on a scale model is very difficult. A bit like trying to simulate handpainting on an AFV, it often looks as if the builder has not done a very good job.

.
I would not really use old paintings to colormatch my model..

. The painter would have used some licence to create a pleasing or impossing picture, which means that either dark or bleached white sails may be wide of the mark...

:-) .
Personaly I think white (light) sails look better, but that's my own preference. I'm always open for new facts and ideas, after all that's how you broaden your knowledge.
And I'm always game for a good boarding.. uhh I mean friendly disscussion. :-) :-)
Harrr
Cheers
Henk