You are viewing the archived version of the site.
Go to modelshipwrights.com for the current dynamic site!
Go to modelshipwrights.com for the current dynamic site!
1⁄350USS Lexington (CV2) 1927-1942
23
Comments
Overview of the Trumpeter kit
This is the first 1:350 scale model warship I’ve built. Given how long it took, it may well be the last. On reflection, building a replica of what was the world’s largest warship throughout her lifetime was perhaps over-ambitious. Perhaps starting in this scale with a whale boat would have been a better idea.
If you like your models smothered with light automatic AA weapons, then you’re in for a treat. If not, then steer well clear of this subject.
The other problem is – it’s an aircraft carrier. Modelling skills are of course transferable across subject matter. By and large, modelling ships, aircraft, AFVs and model railways present very similar challenges. And, by and large, the same solutions are not only ubiquitous, but can actually inform new approaches to different subject matter. So the fact of the matter that this is an aircraft carrier doesn’t actually present any problems in the aircraft modelling skills department. The real issue is whether you are prepared to put in the time to build dozens – literally dozens – of tiny 1:350 scale aeroplanes. Because ship modelling this is not.
Having built five 1:700 scale injection moulded kits I was expecting the finesse exhibited at this scale to be translated to the larger size. I was hugely disappointed. This kit seemed to me to be the 1:700 version scaled up. On reflection, I was wrong to expect this. If this kit had been moulded with sectional thicknesses found on 1:700 scale models it would have warped, twisted and fallen apart in the first breeze. Clearly it had to be moulded with greater thicknesses to retain any structural integrity.
Overall, however, what a sad disappointment this kit is. The quality (or lack) of accuracy places it in my mind in the market for mass-produced kits of popular subjects. How can this be? If it was a Missouri or a Bismarck it would be excusable. But surely, the market for, at best, a marginal subject, depicted at a very time-constrained period in its history (three weeks or less) can only be very small and restricted to a small band of model warship enthusiasts. The very fact that White Ensign Models received only twelve advance orders for their proposed photo-etched set within three months of the release of this model indicates the narrow scope of likely interest. Therefore, what a huge lost opportunity this represents. For a small group of enthusiasts like myself, the release of this kit was akin to an answer to a maiden’s prayer. Not only is it the Lexington. It is the Lexington at the time of the Battle of the Coral Sea. Not only that, it’s in 1:350 scale. It just couldn’t get any better. Unfortunately, it could. What astonishes me is the effort that must have gone into fictionalising so much of the detail when so much effort could have been saved simply by mimicking the builders’ plans.
The Floating Drydock Company plans represent the ship as first completed. Although they are marked up with subsequent changes, the references are to other drawings that are not available (at least from The Floating Drydock Company). Having said this, builders’ drawings are never the whole truth. They still have to be cross-referenced with photographic sources. Fortunately the Lexington was the subject of a lot of photographic coverage in the pre-war era, especially in relation to the widening of the flight deck at the bow and the installation of light AA platforms at the quarters and on the stack.
The areas of greatest conjecture surround the details of her refit prior to the Battle of the Coral Sea. All the surviving photos from this period are published in Classic Warships Publishing Warship Pictorial #11, Lexington Class Carriers. Combining these with textual descriptions in ‘The Lexington Class Carriers’ (Robert C Stern) provides the best possible basis for making judgements on these details.
SO, with the details all laid out on the table, mate, ON to the build!
Comments
Hi Joseph,
Yeah, it was a lot of research. I was DETERMINED to make it abolutely as accurate as possible. What I don't understand is how Trumpeter got so much of it grotesquely wrong. Anyway, thanks for your comments. I sure hope you find my feature useful - from what I've seen the 1:700 from Trumpeter is just a scaled down version of the 1:350 kit, including everything that's wrong with the big one!
JUL 08, 2008 - 05:36 AM
Hi Rui
Well, well, well. I used to be a graphic designer myself as well. And a copywriter. Hence what I hope is a deal of professionalism in my SBS guide.
The whole project spanned two years. I didn't dare start another model in all that time, knowing it would simply delay completion and possibly I would lose my motivation. Sometimes it was very hard to keep going - the progress when doing the armament and the air group seemed so slow. I really had to force myself to keep going.
Thanks for the advice on using Clearcoat on the decals. Actually, that is what I did use, in order to soften the decals so they would lay close on the curved fuselage sides, to get them to stick, and to try and dull them down. All the planes were matt varnished as well, but that still didn't kill the decal edge reflection.
You can see some of my 1:700 stuff at: LINK If you select my name from the top of the menu on the left you can see all my galleries.
By the way, the 1:700 Trumpeter Lexington looks like just a scaled-down version of the 1:350 version, including everything that is wrong and inaccurate. So please, please, do use all the research I did to get it right. I look forward to seeing the result!
Regards, Chris
JUL 08, 2008 - 05:48 AM
Jim
Your comments an honour indeed. I have followed your work over the years at Modelwarships.com and you really are the best. Counting the hours is actually a way of giving myelf a sanity check! Which is why to some extent the whole project took me two years from start to finish.
Regards, Chris
JUL 08, 2008 - 05:53 AM
Thanks for taking time to answer to my questions! 
I have the 1/700 Trumpeter model, for Coral Sea fit, so I guess you have done all the research for me - but still, I have to get the work myself! 
Not for now, but for a "near" future (I am currently working on three projects, one a full scratch all in 1/700).
Thanks for the link, and since my memory is better for graphics, than for names, I can say that I had already seen your Sara / Lex duo  in MW.
Please keep up - keep your ship models afloat!
  
Rui
JUL 08, 2008 - 05:57 AM
Are you sure that thing is a model. It looks so real. In some of those photos it looks too real. Nice job. Amazinglly nice job. Great tribute to those who sailed, fought and died on board the original Lady Lex carrier. Nice work.   
JUL 11, 2008 - 08:46 AM
Hi Chris,
Sorry no plans on any new 1/350 items.
You could use my YC-728 or 829 for an open ammunition lighter. I have some photos of their use as such. 
JUL 15, 2008 - 07:06 AM
Hello Chris:
I just finished reading your build log.  Outstanding work and very well written.  I have this kit, not sure I want to tackle all the inaccuracies vice just building an OOB kit, but, your work is inspirational and you presented a lot of neat ideas to enhance the kit.  I will be referencing your build log when I tackle mine.  Thanks for posting and sharing.
FEB 10, 2015 - 08:49 AM
Mark, I doubt Chris will respond as this is a 7 year old tread and Chris last signed in 7 years ago.
FEB 10, 2015 - 09:13 AM
wow, awesome model building.
well worth resurrecting the thread and feature.   
FEB 11, 2015 - 09:17 AM
Copyright ©2021 by Chris Smithers. _OPINIONS Model Shipwrights, KitMaker Network, or Silver Star Enterrpises. Images also by copyright holder unless otherwise noted. Opinions expressed are those of the author(s) and not necessarily those of Model Shipwrights. All rights reserved. Originally published on: 2008-07-04 00:00:00. Unique Reads: 23646























